Standing Seam Metal Roofing VS The Competition

So, you’ve decided you want a metal roof, huh? The big question now is what kind. Keep reading to see how Standing Seam Metal Roofing VS The Competition turns out.

How much different can R-Panel, U-Panel, and other various forms of Exposed Fastener metal roofs really be versus the much nicer and more desirable standing seam metal roof systems? Well, the answer is quite distinct. Although both systems share some materials and serve the common purpose of covering and safeguarding your home, the benefits and drawbacks of standing seam and exposed fastener systems differ significantly. GreenLight Roofing and Remodeling focuses on the importance of thoroughly evaluating options, including standing seam and exposed fastener systems, to help you select the optimal metal roofing solution for you.

Here, we will explore:

• Standing seam metal roofing’s pros and cons in Texas.
• The good and the bad of exposed fastener metal roofing.
• Guidelines on determining the most suitable metal roof style for your needs.

Standing Seam Metal Roofing:

Standing seam metal roofing is characterized by a hidden clip or fastener metal panel system featuring vertical legs with a broad, flat area between them. The raised seams or vertical legs extend above the flat panel area, and the fasteners are hidden, either using clips or direct attachment to the deck under the vertical leg. Widely utilized in architectural and commercial buildings, standing seam is considered a high-quality system.

Advantages of Standing Seam Metal Roofing:

1. No Exposed Fasteners: Concealed fasteners protect against UV, moisture, wind, and wear over time.
2. Much Better Warranties: Manufacturers offer greatly improved warranties for added protection for your long-term investment.
3. Allows for Thermal Movement: The panels can expand and contract, minimizing issues like oil canning and noise.
4. Longevity & Lifecycle: With a longer lifespan and less maintenance, standing seam outlasts other roofing types.
5. High-Performance Engineered Profile Systems: Engineered to industry standards for wind uplift, air leakage, water penetration, fire resistance, and impact resistance.
6. Sleek, Consistent, & Modern Look: Ideal for architectural applications with clean lines and customizable colors.
7. Architectural Freedom: Suitable for complex designs and structures with various planes.
8. Energy-Efficient: Often made with cool metal roofing materials, reflecting the sun’s rays and reducing cooling system workload.
9. Metal Material Options: Available in various materials like painted aluminum, zinc, and copper.
10. Non-Penetrating Mounting Options: Allows for mounting additions without piercing the roof surface.

Disadvantages of Standing Seam Metal Roofing:

1. Higher Cost: Generally more expensive compared to exposed fastener systems.
2. Less Qualified Contractors Available: Finding skilled installers can be challenging due to the system’s complexity.
3. Labor-Intensive Installation Process: Involves intricate steps like forming panels, correct spacing of clips, and alignment for various systems.
4. Not Suited For Flat Structures: Inappropriate for roofs with less than a 0.5/12 pitch.
5. Harder to Repair or Replace: This is a tedious process, especially for mechanically seamed systems.

Exposed Fastener Metal Roofing:

Exposed fastener metal roofing involves panels secured to the structure through the face of the metal directly into the decking or framing of the roofing system. Widely used in residential, structural, industrial, and agricultural buildings, this system is considered a more economical choice.

Advantages of Exposed Fastener Metal Roofing:

1. Less Expensive: Affordable due to wider panels, thinner gauge metal, lower-quality paint systems, and fewer accessories.
2. No Seaming Required: Installation is less labor-intensive, with panels overlapping and fastening directly.
3. Performs Relatively Well: Holds up well if correctly installed for the environment.
4. More Contractors Have Skills & Tools: Easier installation attracts more contractors with the necessary skills.
5. Better Suited for DIY Projects: Simpler installation allows for homeowner involvement.
6. Can Be Purchased at Big Box Stores: Easily accessible from various suppliers, including major retailers.
7. Provides a Unique Look: A more traditional appearance, suitable for certain geographic areas.

Disadvantages of Exposed Fastener Metal Roofing:

1. Many Roof Penetrations: Numerous holes increase the risk of water penetration and leaks.
2. Fastener Problems: Potential issues like withdrawal, UV degradation, and incorrect installation.
3. More Frequent Maintenance Required: Regular upkeep, especially for fasteners, is necessary.
4. No Weathertight Warranties: Limited warranty options due to the number of roof penetrations.
5. No Low Slope Structures: For roofs with less than a 3/12 pitch this is not suitable.
6. Less Sleek Look: The visible heads of fasteners provide a bumpier appearance.

How to Know Which Metal Roof Style Is Best for Your Project:

Consider the following factors:

1. Your Budget: Standing seam for a sleek look, exposed fastener for cost savings.
2. Maintenance: Standing seam for less frequent maintenance, exposed fastener for hands-on upkeep.
3. Slope/Pitch of the Roof: Standing seam for pitches above 0.5/12, exposed fastener for pitches above 3/12.
4. Who Is Installing the Roof: Standing seam for professional installation, exposed fastener for DIY or budget-friendly contractors.
5. Your Roofing Structure: Both systems are suitable for various structures, based on performance and preference.
6. The Look You Want: Standing seam for a modern aesthetic, exposed fastener for a traditional or rustic look.

Final Thoughts on Standing Seam vs. Exposed Fastener Metal Roofing:

Ultimately, the choice between standing seam and exposed fastener metal roofing depends on your specific needs, preferences, and budget considerations. Each system has its merits and drawbacks, and a well-informed decision ensures satisfaction with your chosen metal roof.